Reverse-time migration and Green’s theorem: Part II – A new and consistent theory that progresses and corrects current RTM concepts and methods

In this paper, part HI of a two paper set, we place Green’s theorem based reverse time migration (RTM), for the first time on a firm footing and technically consistent math-physics foundation. The required new Green’s function for RTM application is developed and provided, and is neither causal, anticausal, nor a linear combination of these prototype Green’s functions, nor these functions with imposed boundary conditions. We describe resulting fundamentally new RTM theory and algorithms, and provide a step-by-step prescription for application in 1D, 2D and 3D, the fatter for an arbitrary laterally and vertically varying velocity field. The original RTM method of running the wave equation backwards with surface reflection data as a boundary condition is not a wave theory method for wave-field prediction, neither in depth nor in reversed time. In fact, the latter idea corresponds to Huygens Principle which evolved and was corrected and became a wave theory predictor by George Green in 1826. The original RTM method, where (1) ‘running the wave equation backward in time’, and then (2) employing a zero lag cross-correlation imaging condition, is in both of these ingredients less accurate and effective than the Green’s theorem RTM method of this two paper set. Furthermore, all currently available Green’s theorem methods for RTM make fundamental conceptual and algorithmic errors in their Green’s theorem formulations. Consequently, even with an accurate velocity model, current Green’s theorem RTM formulations can lead to image location errors and other reported artifacts. Addressing the latter problems is a principal goal of the new Green’s theorem RTM method of this paper. Several simple analytic 1D examples illustrate the new RTM method, We also compare the general RTM methodology and philosophy, as the high water mark of current imaging concepts and application, with the next generation and emerging Inverse Scattering Series imaging concepts and methods.
- Baysal, E., Kosloff, D.D. and Sherwood, J.W.C., 1983. Reverse time migration. Geophysics, 48:
- 1514-1524.
- Berkhout, A.J., 1997. Pushing the limits of seismic imaging. Part II: Integration of prestack
- migration, velocity estimation, and AVO analysis. Geophysics, 62: 954-969.
- Born, M. and Wolf, E., 1999. Principles of Optics: Electromagnetic Theory of Propagation,
- Interference, and Diffraction of Light, 7th Ed. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
- Claerbout, J.F., 1992. Earth Soundings Analysis: Processing versus inversion. Blackwell Scientific
- Publications, Inc., New Jersey.
- Clayton, R.W. and Stolt, R.H., 1981. A Born-WKB3 inversion method for acoustic reflection data.
- Geophysics, 46: 1559-1567.
- Crawley, S., Brandsberg-Dahl, S., McClean, J. and Chemingui, N., 2010. Tti reverse time
- migration using the pseudo-analytic method. The Leading Edge, 29: 1378-1384.
- Dong, S., Luo, Y. Xiao, X. Chavez-Perez, S. and Schuster, G.T., 2009. Fast 3D target-oriented
- reverse-time datuming. Geophysics, 74: WCA141-WCAI51.
- Esmersoy, C., and Oristaglio, M., 1988. Reverse-time wave-field extrapolation, imaging, and
- inversion. Geophysics, 53: 920-931.
- Etgen, J.T, and Michelena, R.J., 2010. Introduction to this special section: Reverse time migration.
- The Leading Edge, 29: 1363-1363.
- Fletcher, R., Fowler, P., Kitchenside, P. and Albertin, U., 2006. Suppressing unwanted internal
- reflections in prestack reverse-time migration. Geophysics, 71: E79-E82.
- Green, G., 1828. An essay on the application of mathematical analysis to the theories of electricity
- and magnetism. Privately published.
- Higginbotham, J., Brown, M., Macesanu, C. and Ramirez, O., 2010. Onshore wave-equation depth
- imaging and velocity model building. The Leading Edge, 29: 1386-1392.
- Huygens, C., 1690. Traite de la Lumiére. Pieter van der Aa, Amsterdam.
- Jin, S. and Xu, S., 2010. Visibility analysis for target-oriented reverse time migration and
- optimizing acquisition parameters. The Leading Edge, 29: 1372-1377.
- Liu, F., Weglein, A.B., Innanen, K. and Nita, B.G., 2006. Multi-dimensional seismic imaging using
- the inverse scattering series. Expanded Abstr., 76th Ann. Internat. SEG Mtg., New Orleans:
- 3026-3030,
- Liu, F., Zhang, G., Morton, S.A. and Leveille, J.P., 2009. An optimized wave equation for seismic
- modeling and reverse time migration. Geophysics, 74: WCA153-WCAIS58.
- Luo, Y. and Schuster, G.T., 2004. Bottom-up target-oriented reverse-time datuming. CPS/SEG
- Geophysics Conference and Exhibition: F55.
- McMechan, G.A., 1983. Migration by extrapolation of time-dependent boundary values. Geophys.
- Prosp., 31: 413-420.
- Morse, P.M. and Feshbach, H., 1953, Methods of Theoretical Physics. McGraw-Hill Book Co.,
- New York,
- 156 WEGLEIN, STOLT & MAYHAN
- Ramirez, A.C. and Weglein, A.B., 2009. Green’s theorem as a comprehensive framework for data
- reconstruction, regularization, wavefield separation, seismic interferometry, and wavelet
- estimation: a tutorial. Geophysics, 74: W35-W62.
- Schneider, W.A., 1978. Integral formulation for migration in two and three dimensions. Geophysics,
- 43: 49-76.
- Stolt, R.H., 1978. Migration by Fourier transform. Geophysics, 43: 23-48.
- Stolt, R.H. and Jacobs, B., 1980. Inversion of seismic data in a laterally heterogenous medium.
- Technical Report 24, SEP, Tulsa, OK.
- Stolt, R.H. and Weglein, A.B., 1985. Migration and inversion of seismic data. Geophysics, 50:
- 2458-2472.
- Symes, W.W., 2007. Reverse-time migration with optimal checkpointing. Geophysics, 72:
- SM213-SM221.
- Toselli, A. and Widlund, O., 2000. Domain Decomposition Methods - Algorithms and Theory.
- Springer Verlag, Berlin.
- Weglein, A.B., Araiijo, F.V., Carvalho, P.M., Stolt, R.H., Matson, K.H., Coates, R.T., Corrigan,
- D., Foster, D.J., Shaw, S.A. and Zhang, H., 2003. Inverse scattering series and seismic
- exploration. Inverse Problems, 19: R27-R83.
- Weglein, A.B., Gasparotto, F.A., Carvalho, P.M. and Stolt, R.H., 1997. An inverse-scattering
- series method for attenuating multiples in seismic reflection data. Geophysics, 62:
- 1975-1989.
- Weglein, A.B., Nita, B.G., Innanen, K.A., Otnes, E., Shaw, S.A., Liu, F., Zhang, H., Ramirez,
- A.C., Zhang, J., Paviis, G.L. and Fan, C., 2006. Using the inverse scattering series to
- predict the wavefield at depth and the transmitted wavefield without an assumption about the
- phase of the measured reflection data or back propagation in the overburden. Geophysics,
- 71(4): S1125-S1137.
- Weglein, A.B. and Secrest, B.G., 1990. Wavelet estimation for a multidimensional! acoustic earth
- model. Geophysics, 55: 902-913.
- Weglein, A.B., Stolt, R.H. and Mayhan, J.D., 2011. Reverse time migration and Green’s theorem:
- Part I - the evolution of concepts, and setting the stage for the new RTM method. J. Seismic
- Explor., 20: 73-90.
- Weglein, A.B., Zhang, H., Ramirez, A.C., Liu, F. and Lira, J.E.M., 2009. Clarifying the
- underlying and fundamental meaning of the approximate linear inversion of seismic data.
- Geophysics, 74: WCD1-WCD13.
- Whitmore, D.N., 1983. Iterative depth imaging by back time propagation. Expanded Abstr., 53rd
- Ann, Internat. SEG Mtg., Las Vegas: 382-385.
- Zhang, J., 2007. Wave theory based data preparation for inverse scattering multiple removal, depth
- imaging and parameter estimation: analysis and numerical tests of Green’s theorem
- deghosting theory. Ph.D. thesis, University of Houston.
- Zhang, Y., Sun, J. and Gray, S., 2007, Reverse-time migration: amplitude and implementation
- issues, Expanded Abstr., 77th Ann. Internat. SEG Mtg., San Antonio, 25: 2145-2149.
- Zhang, Y., Xu, S., Tang, B., Bai, B., Huang, Y. and Huang, T., 2010. Angle gathers from reverse
- time migration. The Leading Edge, 29: 1364-1371.
- RTM AND GREEN'S THEOREM 157